Gold Loan vs Loan Against Shares: Key Differences, Rates, and Comparison
Table of Contents
Loan against shares vs gold loan is a common comparison for borrowers evaluating secured funding options in India. Gold loans typically allow up to 85% LTV as per regulatory norms and are assessed based on gold purity and value. Loans against shares (LAS) enable borrowers to retain ownership of their equity holdings but may involve market-linked risks, including margin requirements.
Both options differ in terms of collateral type, risk profile, and borrowing structure. The choice depends on borrower-specific requirements, asset availability, and lender policies.
What Are Gold Loans and Loans Against Shares?
A gold loan is a secured loan where the borrower pledges physical gold jewellery or coins as collateral. The lender assesses purity and weight, and sanctions a loan based on a percentage of the gold’s market value. These loans are regulated under guidelines issued by Reserve Bank of India, particularly regarding Loan-to-Value (LTV) limits, valuation practices, and borrower protection norms.
A loan against shares (LAS), also referred to as a loan against securities, allows borrowers to pledge equity shares held in a demat account. A lien is marked in favour of the lender through depositories such as Central Depository Services Limited or National Securities Depository Limited. The borrower retains ownership benefits such as dividends, while the lender provides credit based on the portfolio’s value.
Both products fall under the category of secured loans, but differ significantly in collateral type, valuation stability, and risk exposure.
How a Gold Loan Works
The borrower submits gold items (generally 18 carats or above) for evaluation. The lender conducts an assay to determine purity and weight, and calculates the eligible loan amount based on prevailing gold prices. As per regulatory norms, lenders may sanction loans up to 75% of the gold’s value. The process includes compliance with applicable KYC requirements, and pledged gold is stored as per lender security protocols.
How a Loan Against Shares Works
The borrower selects eligible securities from an approved list and authorises pledge creation through their demat account. The lender marks a lien and provides a credit line or loan amount, typically up to 50% of the market value of equities. The borrower continues to receive dividends and corporate benefits. However, if market prices decline, the borrower may face a margin call.
Gold Loan vs Loan Against Shares: Side-by-Side Comparison
| Parameter | Gold Loan | Loan Against Shares |
|---|---|---|
| Interest Rate | Determined by lender policies and disclosed as per regulatory norms | Determined based on securities and lender policies |
| LTV Ratio | Up to 75% (as per RBI norms) | Up to 50% for equities (as per prevailing guidelines) |
| Loan Tenure | As specified by lender, typically short to medium duration | As per facility structure and lender terms |
| Collateral Type | Physical gold | Equity shares |
| Disbursal Time | Post valuation and documentation completion | Post lien marking and approval |
| Documentation | Based on KYC and lender requirements | Includes demat and KYC requirements |
| Margin Call Risk | Not applicable | Applicable if share prices decline |
| Foreclosure Charges | As per lender policy and disclosed upfront | As per facility terms |
| Tax Implications | Depends on end use of funds | Applicable only if shares are sold |
Gold loans and loans against shares differ in borrowing limits, collateral characteristics, and associated risks. Borrowers should evaluate both options based on their financial requirements and risk tolerance.
Key Differences Explained: LTV, Interest Rates, and Risk
This section compares key parameters such as LTV ratio, interest rate, and collateral risk across both products.
Loan-to-Value (LTV) Ratio: What It Means for Your Borrowing Power
LTV determines the proportion of loan available against the value of the pledged asset. For example:
- Gold worth ₹1,00,000 may allow borrowing up to ₹75,000
- Shares worth ₹1,00,000 may allow borrowing up to ₹50,000
The applicable LTV is subject to regulatory caps and lender policies.
Interest Rates: Gold Loans vs Loans Against Shares
Interest rates for both products are determined by the lender based on internal risk assessment, asset type, and prevailing market conditions. Lenders are required to disclose applicable rates and charges transparently in accordance with regulatory guidelines.
Margin Call Risk in Loans Against Shares
A margin call may arise if the value of pledged shares falls below the required threshold. In such cases, the borrower may be required to provide additional collateral or partially repay the loan. If the requirement is not met, the lender may liquidate the pledged securities as per agreed terms. Gold loans do not typically involve such mechanisms.
When Should You Choose a Gold Loan?
A gold loan may be considered in the following situations:
- Availability of eligible gold assets for collateral
- Preference for secured borrowing backed by tangible assets
- Requirement for funding within applicable LTV ratio guidelines
- Familiarity with repayment structures offered by lenders
- Short to medium-term funding requirements
Final selection should be based on lender terms, applicable charges, and individual financial assessment.
When Should You Choose a Loan Against Shares?
A loan against shares may be evaluated in the following scenarios:
- Ownership of eligible securities in a demat account
- Requirement to access liquidity without selling investments
- Willingness to manage collateral risk associated with market fluctuations
- Preference for credit facilities linked to portfolio value
- Ability to meet margin requirements if applicable
Borrowers should assess risks and lender terms before availing such facilities.
Tax Implications: Gold Loan vs Loan Against Shares
Tax treatment differs based on usage and asset class:
- Interest paid on a gold loan used for business purposes may be deductible under Section 37 of the Income Tax Act.
- Pledging shares does not constitute a transfer and does not trigger capital gains tax.
- If pledged shares are sold by the lender due to a margin call, the resulting gain or loss is taxable in the borrower’s hands.
Borrowers should consult a qualified tax advisor for case-specific interpretation.
How to Apply for a Gold Loan or Loan Against Securities at IIFL Finance
Gold Loan Application Steps
- Visit the lender’s branch or apply through the official platform
- Submit gold items for evaluation
- Complete KYC documentation
- Review loan terms and execute the agreement
- Loan amount is disbursed subject to verification and completion of required formalities
Loan Against Shares Application Steps
- Apply through the lender’s platform
- Select eligible securities from the approved list
- Authorise lien marking in the demat account
- Credit limit is activated post verification
- Funds can be utilised within the approved limit
Conclusion
Gold loan vs loan against shares involves a comparison of asset type, regulatory limits, and associated risks. Gold loans are governed by RBI norms with defined LTV caps, while loans against shares are subject to market-linked valuation and margin requirements. Borrowers should evaluate their financial position, asset availability, and risk tolerance before making a decision.
Frequently Asked Questions
Disclaimer : The information in this blog is for general purposes only and may change without notice. It does not constitute legal, tax, or financial advice. Readers should seek professional guidance and make decisions at their own discretion. IIFL Finance is not liable for any reliance on this content. Read more
